On the Bookshelf: The Aesthetics of Proximity in David Hartley’s Observations on Man and Percy Shelley’s ‘Letter to Maria Gisborne’

As the BARS Communications Fellow for 2026-27, I am excited to announce a new blog series On the Bookshelf. Contributions are invited that consider books owned by a writer in the Romantic period that shaped their works and ideas in some way or had emotional significance for them. Contributions might address some of the following questions:

  • How were these books handled by the owner during their lifetime?
  • In what way might these books function as material continuations of the owner’s body after their death?
  • What affective connections might emerge through encounters of the same physical object by subsequent readers and owners in history and in our time?

The blog series aims to explore topics concerning physical relics, afterlives, and the reproducibility of print in the Romantic period. If you would like to submit a piece to the On the Bookshelf series, please don’t hesitate to get in touch with me, Yuan Ge, at yuan.ge496@gmail.com. To launch the series, I am examining how Percy Shelley’s reading of David Hartley’s theory of association in his Observations on Man may have informed the aesthetics of proximity in Shelley’s poetry.

—————————-

In his letter to the engineer Henry Reveley on 28 October 1819, Percy Shelley pointed out the insufficiency and awkwardness of the engineer’s language:

You know our bargain: you are to write me uncorrected letters; just as the words come, so let me have them, – I like coin new from the mint, though it may be a little rough at the edges […] you will not permit a false shame with regard to the mere mechanical arrangement of words, to overbalance the advantage arising from the free communication of ideas.

The letter suggests that the subtle art of weaving words together is a crucial talent that the engineer lacks. Reveley’s writing was a ‘mere mechanical arrangement of words’. The engineer’s letters, for Shelley, were able to provide the raw materials that he, as a poet, could then refine with a more poetic language in his poem ‘Letter to Maria Gisborne’ (1820), which was written in Reveley’s workshop:

Proteus transformed to metal did not make
More figures, or more strange; nor did he take
Such shapes of unintelligible brass,
Or heap himself in such a horrid mass
Of tin and iron not to be understood;
And forms of unimaginable wood,
To puzzle Tubal Cain and all his brood:
Great screws, and cones, and wheels, and grooved blocks,
The elements of what will stand the shocks
Of wave and wind and time.

In these lines, ‘brass’, ‘tin’, ‘iron’, ‘wood’, ‘screws’, ‘cones’, ‘wheels’, and ‘grooved blocks’ are similar to the kinds of materials mentioned in Reveley’s letters to Shelley. They pile on each other in close succession, and this juxtaposition mimics the way mechanical parts interlock with each other. The iambic pentameter of the poem brings together jarring objects so that they fit together sonically. For Shelley, the association and juxtaposition of words in his poetry is able to produce an effect that is not just ‘mechanical’ – the aesthetic proximity between objects in the poem is able to test the limit of the reader’s imagination (‘unintelligible’, ‘not to be understood’, ‘unimaginable’).

Shelley’s juxtaposition of elements in the poem may have been informed by David Hartley’s work on the power of association. He owned and annotated a copy of Hartley’s Observations on Man (1749). Hartley’s thesis is built on the cohesive power accrued by vibrating particles. He builds on Newton’s and Locke’s theories in proposing an intensely materialist account: vibrations in the human brain are like sound waves that transmit and produce ideas. In Ann Wroe’s study of Shelley’s annotations of Hartley’s work, she observes that Shelley is particularly interested when Hartley describes how ‘tremblings […] agitate the brain particles’. Hartley suggests that these tremblings, or vibrations, ‘by being associated together a sufficient Number of Times’, acquire a power that is able to generate simple and complex ideas. Wroe points out that these vibrations cause ‘one idea to automatically suggest the next by sheer physical impulse and proximity in the brain clusters’. For Hartley, particles cohere to produce changes in the material world. He defines association as what happens when ‘infinitesimal parts’ of ‘any ideas, or miniature vibrations’ come to ‘cohere together through joint impression’. Similarly, Shelley believes in how the force of juxtaposition of elements in language can effect perceptual change by evoking a sense of perplexity in the reader.

Through the power of juxtaposition, Shelley manages to measure Reveley’s workshop with his poetry:

                                                      next
Lie bills and calculations much perplexed,
With steam-boats, frigates, and machinery quaint
Traced over them in blue and yellow paint.
Then comes a range of mathematical
Instruments, for plans nautical and statical,
A heap of rosin, a queer broken glass
With ink in it; – a china cup that was
What it will never be again, I think, –

A succession of objects is introduced one after another in close proximity with each other, presenting a disjunctive mass of things that produces an ‘unintelligible’ impression in the observer as the poem refuses aesthetic distance. This is reminiscent of Hartley’s account, where particles cohere to create impressions in the mind. By including a heterogeneous mixture of objects (‘steam-boats’, ‘mathematical [i]nstruments’, ‘rosin’, ‘china cup’), the poem suggests that the power of juxtaposition has the potential to create a productive kind of confusion in the reader by alerting them to the differences between things, rather than subsuming these differences into a Wordsworthian coherent unity.

Shelley’s annotations of Hartley indicate that he was likely informed by Hartley’s theory of association, but his poetry also suggests departures from Hartley. The process of association and vibration, for Hartley, is not limited to an individual being, but will ultimately connect all human bodies in universal happiness and goodness by annihilating individual differences. Shelley’s annotations show that he disagreed with Hartley on this point: he bracketed the passage and wrote the words ‘a Sophism’ in the margin. Indeed, his poetry suggests that aesthetic proximity can serve to preserve the discomfiting juxtapositions of reality without suppressing the differences between its components. We might say that Hartley’s vibrations persist in Shelley’s work at a shifted frequency, where association no longer aims to synchronize diverse bodies, but instead draws our attention to the irreducible multiplicity of things.

Yuan Ge recently passed her PhD viva at King’s College London, where she is working as a Teaching Assistant. Her doctoral research takes a phenomenological approach to study how the perception of rhythms in Percy Shelley’s writing evolved throughout his career, and the way in which Shelley’s rhythmic model exposes the tension between different scales of personal, political, and scientific time in the Romantic period. She has published an article in the Keats-Shelley Journal and a book review in The Keats-Shelley Review. Yuan also has research interests in literature for children in the Romantic period, and she is currently working on an essay on Anna Barbauld’s pedagogy for Mary Fairclough and Joanna Wharton’s edited collection Anna Laetitia Barbauld: Voicing Dissent. She is the blog curator for the BARS On the Bookshelf series and is BARS Communications Fellow 2026-27. She can be contacted at yuan.ge496@gmail.com.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Prove you're human with the power of SIMPLE MATHS (Turing would be proud) *